Friday, December 7, 2012
Stuff My Mother Says
I’ve been thinking about why kids read. Actually, why some kids read … a lot … and some kids don’t.
In the New York Times on Thursday (12/6) there was an article about how even though Latino students make up 25 percent of the school population in the
Latino characters in children’s books are markedly absent. And the “experts” say that’s a problem.
“Education experts and teachers who work with large Latino populations say that the lack of familiar images could be an obstacle as young readers work to build stamina and deepen their understanding of story elements like character,” the article asserts.
(for the full article, see http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/05/education/young-latino-students-dont-see-themselves-in-books.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0)
This got me thinking, not only because I write for young people (teens, not little kids) and did happen to include a Cuban character in one of my books, but also because it made me recall by own bookwormish childhood. I don’t remember “relating” to the characters. If anything, I loved being plucked out of my own world and transported to another. Then again, I grew up in a predominately white, upper middle class town, so maybe that’s why books like “
resonated so deeply with me. I mean, a
white girl is a white girl is a white girl, right? Even if one lives in Jersey
and spends Saturdays cruising the malls on Route 17 and another one lives on a farm and
raises a pet pig. There are certain
basic, cultural “things” we just “get.”
It’s like knowing the secret handshake which allows you into the club.
The comments following the Times article were interesting. One in particular snarkily noted that there are hardly any Asian protagonists in children’s books, but “Who are all the valedictorians in American high schools? Asians.”
Okay, snarky point taken. But these were, after all education experts pointing out this problem for young readers. So I decided to consult my own expert: a bona fide “Latino.”
This gal grew up in an apartment in
York, in the Bronx. Spanish was her first language and Spanish was
spoken at home. Her parents did not go
to college … actually, her father drove a bus down Riverside Avenue. She grew up far from the upper middle class
world of homes stocked with books and newspapers, weekends playing tennis at
the club, adults chatting about their work at “the office.” Yet she was a voracious reader as a child, and
continues to be a lifelong reader and learner.
In other words, I called my mom.
“That’s ridiculous,” she said when I told her about the article. “I read everything I could get my hands on, and I didn’t care what color the characters were. I just loved stories. Kids want a good story.”
“My mother,” she went on, “knew that if we were going to make it in
we had to learn English. So you know
what she got me? A library card. And the Encyclopedia Britannica. This guy came to our door, and he said, ‘Mrs.
Morales, with a dollar down and a dollar every month, you can have the
encyclopedia right here in your home.’
And she went for it. I remember
my brother and I spending hours on the floor reading the encyclopedia. It was wonderful.”
When I asked her how she recalls turning me on to reading, she says, “That was easy. For starters, we were the last people in
to have a color television. Second, if I
saw you laying around I’d say, ‘Either read, or help me clean.’ That got you all reading, let me tell you.”
I remember that. As long as my nose was in a book, mom left me alone.
I know this issue boils down to more than “get a library card” and “clean your room.” It’s more complicated than that. But maybe … not that much more complicated. Maybe we don’t have to reinvent children’s literature, although having more Latino characters (and I mean authentic characters, not just stick figures celebrating Cinco de Mayo) would certainly benefit all readers, especially kids who don’t know any Latinos.
But maybe there’s something to being the last family in
America to have
a color television. I know my kids were
the last in our town to have cable.
Recently I was at a gathering in
Elizabeth, Maine, which, in case
you don’t know Maine,
is probably the area with the highest per capita income in the state. The schools are notoriously good, and when I say “notorious” I mean people talk
about how tough the public high school is and how high the expectations are. Anyway, at this gathering I met a fifth grade
teacher who talked about how concerned she is about her students, especially
her boys, because they aren’t reading.
“I mean, this is
Cape!” she said. “If they aren’t reading here, what’s up?”
We talked about our own kids, all in college now, and how they cut their teeth on the Harry Potter books. They grew up with Harry, built their reading stamina on those loooong books (and really, what did they have in common with British wizards, anyway?) then moved on to “The Lord of the Rings,” C.S. Lewis, Dickens ….
The teacher from
she asked her current students who had read “Harry Potter,” and barely a third
raised their hands. However, when she
asked how many had seen the movies, virtually every child had seen every Harry
Potter movie. Multiple times.
When the power goes out, we light candles, sit around the table, and play cards. Pull out the board games. Talk and laugh. When the lights go back on, we retreat to our screens. Our laptops and iPads and televisions and cell phones.
Maybe, even if the electricity is on, we should abandon the screens and open our books. Stretch out on the floor with the Encyclopedia Britannica and criss-cross the globe. Lift our heads every once in a while to comment to the person across the room, “Hey, listen to this,” and read a few lines out loud.
I think that’s how my mother did it.